Pro & cons of zero tolerance in schools

Written by andrew rothmund | 13/05/2017
Pro & cons of zero tolerance in schools
Zero tolerance policies in schools are strongly supported and opposed by different sides of the debate. (Jupiterimages/ Images)

While the term "zero tolerance" can have a variety of meanings, it usually refers to a set of policies that strictly and quickly punish students for infractions against school regulations, usually involving drugs, alcohol or academic dishonesty. There are advantages and disadvantages to zero tolerance policies, making the debate between the two sides heated and complicated.


Pro & cons of zero tolerance in schools
Some students can be wrongfully accused of infractions and deviant behaviour under any policy system. (Jupiterimages/ Images)

Under zero tolerance school policies, there is a heightened risk of innocent students being punished for behaviour that they did not exhibit, or behaviour that is misinterpreted or misconstrued. Students with psychological disorders, such as attention deficit disorder, may act outwardly and rashly through no fault of their own. It is argued that these types of students need professional care and attention, rather than strict punishment.


Pro & cons of zero tolerance in schools
The harshness of a certain punishment can either prevent behaviour, or falsely suppress it. (Thomas Northcut/Lifesize/Getty Images)

The severity of zero tolerance punishments is hotly debated -- some supporters maintain that these punishments are very effective at preventing deviant behaviour, and some opponents maintain that they harm a student's opportunities to improve or gain access to help. For example, suspending or expelling a student because of a drug infraction may remove the student from the school's support system, making him or her more likely to commit further drug infractions.


Pro & cons of zero tolerance in schools
Student safety is the paramount concern, hence the debate over whether or not zero tolerance is the safest policy. (Jupiterimages/Creatas/Getty Images)

The safety of students is always the top priority of administration, teachers and parents, and because of this, some supporters say that removing deviant or dangerous students from the student body will prevent bad influences from reaching other students. Opponents say that student bodies aren't as affected by the influence of a few deviant individuals, and that the community as a whole can benefit from providing help and support for those who need it.


Pro & cons of zero tolerance in schools
Consistent regulations are sometimes considered the most just regulations, but they can also be too severe. (Jupiterimages/Comstock/Getty Images)

Zero tolerance policies are consistent, meaning that there are clear-cut and unarguable punishments for each specific behaviour and infraction. This usually means that students are well aware of the consequences for their actions, and that they must be responsible for their decisions. However, some maintain that students sometimes lose control of themselves, and aren't always responsible for misbehaving or violating policies.

By using the site, you consent to the use of cookies. For more information, please see our Cookie policy.