Poured walls vs. concrete block
Concrete blocks and poured concrete can be compared and contrasted in a number of ways.
Although poured concrete is stronger than concrete blocks, it is a bit more expensive, and although blocks are cheaper to install than poured concrete, they are more likely to seep and retain water, thus allowing penetration of moisture to an interior wall.
In 2002, the cost of installing blocks per square foot was roughly £1.90, including labour and materials. During the same year, the cost of installing poured concrete was around £3 per square foot, including material and labour. As of 2010, even though the labour cost has remained the same, the material costs have risen by 60p. However, these costs change when you remove the labour cost from the two and decide to do it yourself. The concrete block price drops by 60p per square foot, and the poured concrete price drops by £1.90. These prices may also vary from location to location.
Concrete blocks must be laid one single block at a time, whereas poured concrete is installed in one monolithic structure, which naturally makes the unit stronger; however, concrete blocks can be laid with type S mortar and have every fourth block cell filled solid with concrete and rebar, but, generally, block construction is best for projects that will not exert very much horizontal pressure on the construction of the blocks. Poured concrete serves best when it is installed as a barrier or retaining wall. This type of construction will hold off tons of pressure.
Poured concrete can be used as retaining walls where large amounts of soil may need to be held back. This works well in full-house basements where one or two of the basement walls are completely below the surface of the dirt. Poured concrete is also great for landscape retaining walls where high banks are desired or erosion is a problem.
Concrete blocks are great for house foundations where no side force is exerted on the construction--only the downward force of the house. Cinder blocks are also acceptable for house walls, dividing walls and landscaping projects that do not require structural support.
Most problems in each application occur because of poor installation. A poured concrete installation will crack and settle if the footers are poorly installed, such as if they are too thin or are not wide enough to support the weight of the poured concrete.
Concrete blocks are prone to water penetration because of the porous nature of the block materials. The block joints may also break down over time, thus allowing the structure to crumble and deteriorate.
Poured concrete problems can be solved by making sure that plenty of rebar is installed in the wet concrete to prevent separation of the materials once they dry. Make sure that the footing for the poured concrete is at least 12 inches thick and 16 inches wide.
You can prevent concrete block problems by using type S mortar for the installation and by painting a water barrier paint onto the surface of the blocks.
- "Habitat for Humanity; How to Build a House"; Larry Haun, Millard Fuller, Vincent Laurence; 2002
- "Recommended Practices for Laying Concrete Block"; Portland Cement Association; 1992
- "2010 National Concrete and Masonry Estimator"; Craftsman Book Company; 2010