Silicone and nylon are two inventions of the 20th century. They are both synthetic creations and neither was initially invented for use in the kitchen. However, over the years, cooks have hijacked both polymers for their own uses. While the substances are similar, there are some key differences between the two.
On average, nylon is the cheaper material. A set of nylon tools costs roughly half as much as a similar set of silicone tools. Some upscale silicone tools can be about three times as much. This is because silicone is more expensive to produce, especially if it is free of fillers. Nylon is used in many disposable products such as food containers or the straps on garbage bags. That doesn't mean its totally worthless though.
Nylon and silicone are far more stick resistant than many other materials, such as metal for example. Some specially designed silicone pads are completely non-stick. Most silicone utensils, especially if they have fillers, are just stick resistant. Nylon utensils are similarly stick resistant. Both make good spatulas and spoons. Silicone, though, is the only one durable enough as actual cookware and is non-stick or stick resistant. Nylon containers should not be used for actual cooking.
Ware and Tear
Both silicone and nylon utensils will not damage metal pots or pans. They are preferable to metal utensils, which scratch off the coating on pans and skillets. Scrubs and cleaning brushes are often made of nylon. The material is very effective in cleaning cookware without damaging it like steel wool does. It also resists bacteria better compared to your average sponge. Silicone utensils, however, are much more durable than nylon. They require a higher temperature to melt as well.
Because of its durability, silicone is the better choice for the environment. Nylon is cheap and easily replaced, but utensils will just sit in a landfill once thrown away. Both these polymers take years to break down. Disposable items made of nylon, such as food containers, add to landfills. Investing in a quality set of silicone utensils is better than burning through several cheap sets of nylon ones.
- "Plastics and the Environment"; Anthony L. Andrady; 2003
- "Joy of Cooking"; Irma von Starkloff Rombauer and Marion Rombauer Becker; 1975
- "Gluten-Free Quick & Easy: From Prep to Plate Without the Fuss : 200+ Recipes for People With Food Sensitivities"; Carol Fenster; 2007
- "Encyclopedia of Kitchen History"; Mary Ellen Snodgrass; 2004
- "Cooking Green: Reducing your Carbon Footprint in the Kitchen : The New Green Basics Way"; Kate Heyhoe; 2009