The Cons of Whistle Blowing

Written by patrick stothers kwak
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Pin
  • Email
The Cons of Whistle Blowing
Whistle blowing can damage trust in the workplace. (Jupiterimages/Comstock/Getty Images)

A whistle blower is an individual who informs the public or an authority about alleged misconduct within the workplace. Whistle blowing can occur within the context of the government, a public organisation or a company; alleged misconduct can include violations of the law, regulations, threats to the public interest and corruption. While whistle blowing is an important method of self-regulation, there are certain risks associated with being a whistle blower.

Diminishes Trust in the Workplace

Reporting the misconduct of your fellow employees may be good for enforcement of company policy, but it can also seriously diminish trust between you and the rest of the workplace. Simply put, nobody likes a tattletale. Even if the person being reported was indeed at fault, other employees may feel they cannot trust you with personal information and they may keep you at a distance.

Can Negatively Affect Your Career

Whistle blowing can incite a variety of hostile responses from upper management, depending on the severity of the allegations being brought to light. As whistle blowing essentially bypasses the chain of command, those being circumvented -- for instance, your direct superior -- can feel slighted or humiliated. Say, for instance, that you are bringing a complaint about the conduct of your manager to the district manager. If the district manager -- who may see the allegations as either insignificant or unverifiable -- takes no action, this can result in a rift between you and your manager. Because of this rift, you may be passed up for promotion or marginalised within the department.

Risk to Personal Safety

Though it is rare, whistle blowers can face risks to their personal safety. Karen Silkwood, for example, was an employee at the now defunct Kerr-McGee nuclear power plant and intended to bring serious safety allegations to light. She died mysteriously in a car crash in 1974 after receiving numerous death threats. The documents she intended to use as proof against Kerr-McGee were not found in the wreckage but an autopsy revealed she had been exposed to lethal doses of radiation and was possibly drugged.

Can Destroy the Company

Bringing serious cases of misconduct or illegal actions to light may be the ethical thing to do from a corporate social responsibility perspective, but it can also result in significant collateral damage. For instance, if the company you are whistle blowing against closes doors or at least loses business as a result, the employees of that firm can suddenly be laid off or can lose their benefits. These consequences should be considered when making the decision to blow the whistle.

Don't Miss

  • All types
  • Articles
  • Slideshows
  • Videos
  • Most relevant
  • Most popular
  • Most recent

No articles available

No slideshows available

No videos available

By using the site, you consent to the use of cookies. For more information, please see our Cookie policy.