DISCOVER
×

How to thicken buttercream frosting

Updated February 21, 2017

Buttercream frosting is a classic for not only covering your favourite cake, but for decorating it as well. While there are two main variations of buttercream -- American buttercream and meringue-based buttercream in either the Italian or Swiss style -- the easiest to make is the American version. Buttercream typically consists of either butter or shortening, mixed with icing sugar and a couple of other ingredients. It is creamy, smooth and easily customised in your choice of flavours or colours. While a simple layer of frosting over your cake requires a thinner frosting, to create elaborate piping and decorations dictates a thicker blend.

Prepare your preferred recipe of buttercream frosting, blending the butter or shortening with icing sugar. Decrease the liquid -- usually water or cream -- used to thin buttercream frosting after mixing. Add the liquid, little by little, stirring to test the consistency after each addition. Stop once your buttercream frosting reaches the thickness you require.

Mix your favourite buttercream recipe, following directions completely. Add additional icing sugar, 3 or 4 tbsp at a time, to thicken the completed frosting. Mix thoroughly, stopping once the frosting reaches the stiffness you desire.

Submerge the bowl of buttercream frosting in ice-cold water, taking care to keep the water level below the bowl rim.

Alternatively, put the bowl of frosting in the refrigerator or freezer to chill. In very warm temperatures, buttercream frosting has a tendency to "melt" and run.

Use shortening instead of butter in your favourite buttercream frosting recipe. Shortening holds up better in the heat, producing a thicker finished frosting when you are ready to serve your cake.

Soften butter for use in your buttercream frosting at room temperature. Microwaving butter causes it to liquefy, which will alter the thickness of your buttercream frosting. Adding more icing sugar will thicken it, but the texture will not be the same.

Tip

Avoid using butter-flavoured shortenings, which may alter the taste of your buttercream frosting.

Warning

Sometimes no matter what you do, your buttercream frosting will just be off, as if in answer to mysterious elements. Making buttercream frosting can prove something of an art, and you have to experiment with what works for you.

Cite this Article A tool to create a citation to reference this article Cite this Article

About the Author

Karie Fay earned a Bachelor of Science in psychology with a minor in law from the University of Arkansas at Monticello. After growing up in construction and with more than 30 years in the field, she believes a girl can swing a hammer with the best of them. She enjoys "green" or innovative solutions and unusual construction.